Retirement: The revision of your identity
Last evening a friend came for dinner; Sophie retired as of January 1st. Though she beamed when she made the announcement, after a glass of wine, she asked me, "What do you do?"
My activity report probably sounded prosaic: some writing, a good deal of reading, walking, the gym, housekeeping, seeing friends and family. The occasional exhibit or concert, the eternal French classes. I recently learned how to make lipstick.
I could see that she thought, That's it? If one's work life has included a front-row pew at the Shrine of Productivity, if one's performance has been measured by deals or bonuses or awards, suddenly there is neither the focus of goals nor the glow of achieving them. Sophie had gone, from one day to the next, from intense, draining work to leisure, and the shift had caught her by surprise.
A productive person who retires thinks she should replace work with other engrossing activities, from Day One. She forgets that at twenty or twenty-five she was sorting out her work preferences. That's when she learned she is happiest working in a team, or hates offices, or is more entrepreneurial than she thought. She may have chosen an occupation, only to find years of training only confirm what she had hoped to ignore: she's just not engaged by law, or the family business, or teaching biology.
Forty years later, we don't permit ourselves that re-assessment when we leave work. Some become anxious, some stick with jobs they don't enjoy because they wonder what else to do. (And some like their work so much that they simply sidestep the whole concept.)
There's concern about boredom. As I used to tell my sons when they were around nine and would sometimes whine, "I'm bored", "If you're bored, it's because you are boring."
At sixty-plus, no one is going to spread Legos on the floor for you; you have to go out and sample things. You can still learn practically anything, from programming to t'ai chi, and you'll be the better for it—but you have to go back to being a beginner. I always wanted to know how to string pearls and I have yards of bloodstained thread to prove that it is harder than it looks.
And it takes time to shed the deep wiring of being the one who Gets It Done. I still have a visceral sense of tension on Sunday evenings, as if my nervous system is still gearing up for the week; I dream about my work—not quite nightmares, but the level below, where things are not going well and it is my fault.
It is only in the past year, after five years of retirement, that my brain is starting to realize, You don't have that stress anymore.
So I recognized that slightly stunned look Sophie had, that tentative sense of excitement mixed with honest worry. Love and work, we have long been told, are the cornerstones of life. Without work of the paid-employment sort, the identity wobbles, the ego starts to question self-worth and competence.
I haven't left all aspects of my work identity behind. My professional writing background morphed into blogging. When I worked part time for six months of last year, I saw that I had a lot more "general" left in me than "grunt". I tried to take orders graciously and present ideas as "suggestions", which Le Duc predicted that would be out of character, and he was right. You can take the woman out of the corner office, but...
There is no one left to lead but myself, no one to whom I must answer, and no one telling me how valuable I am to the enterprise. I don't miss that validation, but realize I am responsible for finding meaning, and that is what is dawning on Sophie.
So, back to the mindset at twenty: What calls? What could I be?
Perhaps it is finally making a better habitat for her beloved birds, perhaps it is organizing self-care classes for women in shelters (Sophie was an aesthetician), perhaps it's attending every interesting lecture at the Blue Met Literary Festival, after years of only being able to get to one.
You carry your work history into retirement, and some of hums away in the background. But an interesting thing happened to me in December: I lost decades of work I'd stored digitally, due to a Bermuda Triangle of IT issues. At first I panicked and considered expensive data recovery services, but then I realized, It's the past. One of my colleagues marvelled at my equanimity. "The sand covers your footprints pretty fast", I replied.
And as long as I can keep making new footprints, on new paths, there is no regret.
My activity report probably sounded prosaic: some writing, a good deal of reading, walking, the gym, housekeeping, seeing friends and family. The occasional exhibit or concert, the eternal French classes. I recently learned how to make lipstick.
I could see that she thought, That's it? If one's work life has included a front-row pew at the Shrine of Productivity, if one's performance has been measured by deals or bonuses or awards, suddenly there is neither the focus of goals nor the glow of achieving them. Sophie had gone, from one day to the next, from intense, draining work to leisure, and the shift had caught her by surprise.
A productive person who retires thinks she should replace work with other engrossing activities, from Day One. She forgets that at twenty or twenty-five she was sorting out her work preferences. That's when she learned she is happiest working in a team, or hates offices, or is more entrepreneurial than she thought. She may have chosen an occupation, only to find years of training only confirm what she had hoped to ignore: she's just not engaged by law, or the family business, or teaching biology.
Forty years later, we don't permit ourselves that re-assessment when we leave work. Some become anxious, some stick with jobs they don't enjoy because they wonder what else to do. (And some like their work so much that they simply sidestep the whole concept.)
There's concern about boredom. As I used to tell my sons when they were around nine and would sometimes whine, "I'm bored", "If you're bored, it's because you are boring."
At sixty-plus, no one is going to spread Legos on the floor for you; you have to go out and sample things. You can still learn practically anything, from programming to t'ai chi, and you'll be the better for it—but you have to go back to being a beginner. I always wanted to know how to string pearls and I have yards of bloodstained thread to prove that it is harder than it looks.
And it takes time to shed the deep wiring of being the one who Gets It Done. I still have a visceral sense of tension on Sunday evenings, as if my nervous system is still gearing up for the week; I dream about my work—not quite nightmares, but the level below, where things are not going well and it is my fault.
It is only in the past year, after five years of retirement, that my brain is starting to realize, You don't have that stress anymore.
So I recognized that slightly stunned look Sophie had, that tentative sense of excitement mixed with honest worry. Love and work, we have long been told, are the cornerstones of life. Without work of the paid-employment sort, the identity wobbles, the ego starts to question self-worth and competence.
I haven't left all aspects of my work identity behind. My professional writing background morphed into blogging. When I worked part time for six months of last year, I saw that I had a lot more "general" left in me than "grunt". I tried to take orders graciously and present ideas as "suggestions", which Le Duc predicted that would be out of character, and he was right. You can take the woman out of the corner office, but...
There is no one left to lead but myself, no one to whom I must answer, and no one telling me how valuable I am to the enterprise. I don't miss that validation, but realize I am responsible for finding meaning, and that is what is dawning on Sophie.
So, back to the mindset at twenty: What calls? What could I be?
Perhaps it is finally making a better habitat for her beloved birds, perhaps it is organizing self-care classes for women in shelters (Sophie was an aesthetician), perhaps it's attending every interesting lecture at the Blue Met Literary Festival, after years of only being able to get to one.
You carry your work history into retirement, and some of hums away in the background. But an interesting thing happened to me in December: I lost decades of work I'd stored digitally, due to a Bermuda Triangle of IT issues. At first I panicked and considered expensive data recovery services, but then I realized, It's the past. One of my colleagues marvelled at my equanimity. "The sand covers your footprints pretty fast", I replied.
And as long as I can keep making new footprints, on new paths, there is no regret.
Comments
I am lucky enough to have access to an Outplacement Firm (don't you love the phrasing) - and they have given me some good ideas. I plan on working part-time for the next few years - either a few days a week or a serious of contract jobs - at least that's what I'm hoping to find. Ideally gradually easing off - going to 4 days a week and then 3 - before finally retiring had been my plan and having spoken with friends, I think this is a great way to transition, if it's feasible.
In the meantime I've been trying to seek out all those things that are available to do for either free - or at low cost - and I've actually found quite a few things - even in an expensive city like Toronto. I also have a membership to the Art Gallery of Ontario and plan on getting one for the Royal Ontario Museum (although if money is tight then each has free evenings) - I also keep up a theatre membership with a group of friends so that we get 7 major shows a year for $200 (the cheapest seats but we still see and hear everything). I have started Chair-Yoga classes (for those with mobility issues and it's pay what you can) and I take a language class once a week - I think it's important to have a variety of things to do. I'm also planning on visiting a number of different churches for Sunday services over the next few weeks - I was raised within 3 different denominations as a child so I think it will be interesting to return as an adult and really assess what I hear - I may end up joining or I may not.
I don't think I've had an issue of self-worth as I had let that go a few years ago as far as it related to work - I finally reached the point where I could say "Work is what I do to pay the bills - it's not who I am as a person". I have had issues with that Protestant Work Ethic - I feel guilty about "wasting" time - and have found being a bit lazy difficult - although it's getting easier. I think if I was to win a wee bit on the lottery so that I didn't have to return to work that I could now adjust rather well.
I've had this discussion with friends and generally speaking found the following:
.Most seem to enjoy part-time work, at least for a few years
.Women seem to adjust better than men, they seem to have more interests/hobbies & more friends to turn to
.It's important to have some structure to your week
.Yes, it's nice to have extra money and be able to travel but even if finances are strained there is still a lot out there to do and to enjoy.
Thank you for yet another thought provoking post!
The two major expense categories for retirees (in Canada) are housing and transportation. Other than necessities like food and utilities, many other budget categories can be managed by, as you point out, scouting for free events or PWYC performances, or by activities like co-operative dinners, which are lots of fun but not costly.
As for travel, while I fully acknowledge the wonders of seeing the world, travel is a form of consumption. Many will sacrifice to do it, but other people look at the cost, and figure they can do a lot more in their own location, or nearby.
After 6 years of retirement, the winters have become a bit of a concern, can't seem to find the right mix as winter sports are not my thing. The cold weather also de-motivates me (is that a word? oh well). And of course it's fatally easy to while away major time online! Writing this, I see that I need to push forward with my learn-to-make-beaded-jewellery idea which has fallen by the wayside.
Agree that structure is important. Regular stretching/pilates/ etc. classes provide some of that and get me outside the house. I also spend time lunching with friends and am very involved with my nephew, an unexpected bonus at this time of my life.
In many ways this is a wonderful time of life for me just wish my late husband was here to share in it and carry out all the plans we made. It can be lonely.
All of which is to say, this is a very relevant post for me, and good to remember this is shared territory and it's absolutely okay to feel at least ambivalent about what is really quite a lovely privilege most of the time.
And in an echo of your posts on uneven aging, the person who is leaving the job is about to turn 63 and had hoped to continue full-time work until she was 65, but her husband is not well. She told me that she felt she needed to spend time with him now, not in 2 years.
Boredom is not at all on my radar...I am trying to find time in my week for a regular volunteer job opportunity but my days are full...and I never dreamt that retirement could be so full of pleasant activities...I thought it would be quiet and lonely...I am very happy to report its completely the opposite.
You know what they say...retirees never get a day off!
"better ideas" and get bored quite easily. Phase 2 means committing to those volunteer opportunities that I enjoy (leading seniors'
book club, language and literacy in Mexico) and dropping those that just don't suit me. As my husband and I have very different interests, I have reconciled myself to the fact that we're not going to be one of those "Freedom 55+" retirement couples. Friends and community will play a more important role in my life than in the lives of others with different marital relationships or with grandchildren.
We do need to assess our situations in Early Retirement so that we can navigate the transitions of uneven ageing, loss of parents and partners, physical and economic limitations. You have been discussing some really relevant topics and I appreciate the opportunity to exchange ideas and feelings.
The thing that has given me greatest meaning and pleasure however is joining my local Rotary Club. Last year I was the President which a huge year for me, but we accomplished so many wonderful things. We were able to rebuild two kindergartens that were destroyed in Fiji and protect their water supply with a spring box. We are hoping to build a new kindergarten each year on other remote Fijian islands which will give them their first access to ANY education. We hosted an exchange student from Brazil. We put on a Jazz Black tie Ball, a Christmas market for homemade, home grown, hand produced goods, we put on a Super heroes dance and auction to raise money for a local toddler with leukemia, several sausage sizzles to support community events and much more. Being part of the community and giving back, and making a difference, gives your life so much meaning.
materfamilias: A major move consumes a person. But even then, I was still tenuously anchored in my professional world, and a move is a great project-management exercise, catnip to "productive" personalities. Now, I have to make much more conscious choices abut where to put my energy, and I notice from your blog that you are, too.
Jean Shaw: I hope you get the full time job, if you want it. When I worked nearly full time for a period last year, I was surprised how tired I was; I had kind of forgotten the incremental drain of five days in a row.
angiemanzi: She had clients just begging her to stay, even one day a week. It's hard to leave that kind of appreciation. But she also knows she can return if she wants. Many of us do not have that option.
hostess: Sounds like you have adapted beautifully.
Mme: I think you've nailed it, realizing there is not one retirement model, and that what interests a partner or friends will not attract you, necessarily. One of my friends announced her goal: 220 days of golfing a year, and I realized we would see little of one another- but she is doing what she longed to do.
Lynn L: I continue to mentor several younger colleagues- who are now over 40, yikes! I helped one with his book, which was deeply rewarding. If you enjoy student contact, there are ways to maintain it and I wonder if your institution has a mentoring program.
Melissa Hebbard: Thank you for your endorsement of community service! So heartening to read what your club is doing. I find SAHMs who 'grow' along with their children and transfer that caring to the community have generally satisfying transitions.
Mary: 100 mile commute! I have long felt a long commute is one of the least-acknowledged stressors. And it sounds like, given the tenor of your workplace, shedding your work identity will not be an issue.
Sharon: A health-related retirement, whether through health or layoff is an entirely different thing than a voluntary one, as the identity gets a jolt instead of a gentle segue. But, I think your husband is right, and I bet there are volunteer groups who would deeply appreciate your experience.
Thank you.
I have friends who speak of the boredom. It is something I find hard to understand as I truthfully have never had a boring day in my life. I think since my creativity was fostered and encouraged from childhood it is always a place to go to without even thinking about it. I consider it a blessing. I have friends who have been very creative pre retirement and they just stop and then speak of boredom. I think boredom is often self imposed. I mean no disparagement to anyone but since I've never experienced it I find it hard to understand. I guess I'm just the Nike "just do it" type.
Thanks for you wonderful post and I appreciate all the great viewpoints and comments expressed.
Kristien62: "I hadn't made a mark or done anything meaningful" is a point of view that is truly a double-edged situation. If someone smiles when he or she sees you, or has a memory of seeing you, that's meaningful. Our culture is achievement-fixated, especially on the big markers, but most people live lives of more modest successes, contributing in ways that are not commemorated. But, if a person does not feel she has made an adequate contribution, there is so much to do.