The risk of old-money style

When Le Duc saw the New York Times style article, "Style Secrets of Milanese Women", he asked if I had read it. I had not; and I glanced at the photos and said, "The 'secret' is apparently money."

Normally I would blur these women's faces, but they have already been in NYT's print and digital editions, so here's the full-moolah monty:


I see these ladylike uniforms in my city, too, though not often in my neighbourhood, where grown women prefer a more relaxed look, like the friends I saw on the bus in very good sportswear (the green tee and the beige hoodie were cashmere; their jewellery was discreetly luxe.) These women chattted in French, but I couldn't tell if they were local or visiting.

We don't know the occasion for which the three Milanesa gathered; perhaps it demanded more formal attire, but I found their choices staid and dated. 

Scott Schuman, now based in Milan, is celebrating twenty years of his renowned street photography; he sometimes includes women of their vintage. For my (imaginary) money, my picks would be more like these other Italian women he shot:

Photos: Scott Schuman, posted on The Sartorialist

If you want to "look rich" it's not hard to find the sciura trio's clothing; designers still make it. However, when in the Passage, head-to-toe clichéd choices will result in the statement of calcified wealth without any glow of personality.  

"Maybe they like it", generously says my Italian friend Ava, of the first trio. Do you?


 

 



Comments

noreen said…
the second trio of ladies certainly look better than the first but both trios look better in my opinion than the two ladies on the bus who look like a little more effort would have gone a long way
Jean S said…
I'd love to know what they were talking about! The one on the left looks particularly dour (perhaps they had been to a funeral?).

Yes, to my eye, they look a bit like fossils, sprung loose from a '60s time capsule. But as your friend says, perhaps they like their style! And perhaps their choices make them feel like they never have to explain who they are and where they stand. (In contrast, the ladies on the bus....who can say? A bit incognito, perhaps.)

I had forgotten about The Sartorialist, and this sent me to his IG site. Fun.

Wendy said…
Never having visited Milan, I wonder if that trio is perhaps dressed appropriately for their surrounds. I love a dressier outfit (though have little use for one myself), but it’s the sea of neutrals that makes it a no-go for me!
royleen said…
The Milanese women’s hair styles are especially dated. Oh, thank you for the reminder about The Satorialist! I do miss Bill Cunningham.
Allison said…
The first three ladies do look like they have been to a somewhat sombre function or had gathered for lunch to have a serious discussion! They don’t look so much like old money as dated and rather trussed up. The one on the far right does appear to have a flirtatious slit at the front of her trousers although a staid three inches in length. The hair is a little too unnaturally blonde and lacquered. The bottom three look like a lot more fun and are dressed to move not stand around gossiping…it’s just the huge bag that I have trouble with but perhaps she is going to the market? The two on the bus are my favourites! So very Montréal, chic with their understated cashmere. The lady in the green tee reminds me of so many Montréal women I see. Appropriately yet stylishly dressed for the outing yet somehow it’s always elevated by good textiles, bags and discreet but interesting jewellery and the hair is not over coiffed. They manage to avoid the cookie cutter effect of the first three ladies of Milan. The green T lady could toss a little navy blazer on and change her shoes and head over to a cinq à sept at the neighbours!

The posts with the most