The perfume is too damn high

One of my all-time favourite perfumes in INeKE's "Jaipur Chai", to which I was introduced when Beth, who wears INeKE's "Field Notes From Paris" bought a Discovery Set and passed along her sample after testing it once. A smash hit, so Le Duc gave me a full-sized bottle.

Photo: Bill O'Such for INeKE

Nicked for niche

Fast forward a couple of years: bottle on last drops, and INeKE, based in San Francisco, announced a sale. (The regular price is $US 145; it is currently out of stock.) There's an added complication: Because Canada classifies perfume as "dangerous goods" when imported to Canada from the US, it must ground-shipped—even for a single bottle. INeKE charged $US 40 to ground ship via UPS.

A week after delivery, UPS sent its own invoice, with these additional charges (all in $CAN):


There was zero duty because the product is US-made so complies with the current Canada-US-Mexico trade agreement. However, the Canadian sales taxes (which I expected to pay) and "entry prep fee"  (which I did not) pushed the total shipping/handling to $CAN 105. Do not tell Le Duc. 


Eau Canada

For several grumpy days, I considered buying only fragrances made in Canada, or at least those sold locally. 
Photo: Zoologist Perfumes

Top candidates are Monsillage and ZoologistThe two makers could not be more different; Monsillage fragrances are sparkling and graceful, Zoologist's quirky and intense. These will even ship free above an easy-to-reach limit and I'd get angel points for supporting small parfumeurs imperilled by the US-imposed tariffs on their products shipped to American customers.

No matter where you live, if your favourite scent must cross a border, I have three strategies to reduce the cost:

1. Find a new love that doesn't break the bank 

Prestige brands are now about 30% higher than before the pandemic. Reasons given include increase in materials costs, tariffs, and corporate greed. There are, however, bargains to be found and small artisanal houses have even reduced their prices to stay in business. 

First, order 1ml decants from Perfumeniche (Toronto). Gwen, Perfumeniche's owner, knows perfume like Otani knows pitches. and ships to Canada for free. She will help if you're interested in a new scent. For readers in other countries: Do the same via a local company similar to Perfumeniche, such as Decanted.uk

Don't try to replicate your spendy favourite; find one that brings a fresh frisson; for example, if your fetish scent is "Carnal Flower" (Malle), now at $CAN 390 for 50ml, try a lower-priced white floral that pleases. Don't fall for dupes, they are nearly always harsh, unsatisfying, weak or all three.

For maximum cost-trimming, restrict your sampling to locally-made brands or those offered by discounters like those in the next step.

2. Scout discounts on both product and shipping

Open an account at companies like FragranceBuy, FragranceX and FragranceNet, discounters with good reputations. They'll sometimes offer free shipping, either on special promo days or via their loyalty programs. Near the holidays, FragranceNet free-shipped a bottle of Serge Lutens and added only $5.50 handling, with no ugly post-delivery charges. (Their courier is Landmark Global.)

Discounters, though, may never carry the fragrance you want, or it sells out in a flash.

Stores and independent fragrance companies have occasional sales too, often in mid-November to December. In November, Holt Renfrew discounted its Malle line (owned by Estee Lauder), as did another of my favourite houses, Miller Harris, on all their products. Join their mailing lists to track these.  

3. Buy when you travel, or ask a friend to fetch it

For qualified visitors, many countries waive their local tax; check the rules and process. Make sure you or your friend can handle the paperwork and inspection routine; a loving spouse is up for it, but Aunt Gina on her first-ever trip to Paris may be daunted. 

Then, if it's brought back by air, pack to comply with the airline's regs.

Typical packing for carry-on liquids

Review the carrier's rules for perfume and brief the friend if carrying it is new to them. Lynn asked her partner Sue to bring her a little bottle of Tom Ford Black Orchid when she flew to Boston on business. Sue generously bought the 120ml bottle instead, packed it in her carry-on, and Logan airport security confiscated that, because it exceeded the 100ml limit. (She could not check her bag at that point.)

Arrival duties and taxes: If the traveller uses her entire personal exemption for other purchases, your bottle will not be duty-free, and that includes any from a duty-free store.  (For returning Canadians, the $60 gift exemption applies to a gift from someone, not for them.)

For multi-country trips, the purchase must be declared at each entry point; in general, you will not have to pay duty on perfume, though some countries (India is one) may assess it if you are not in transit.

I have learned to say, when asked to bring home a Longchamps bag or French cosmetics, "I am happy to do that, but I always use my personal exemption, so are are you OK with paying the duty on this?" 

Breaking bad

There are outlaw ways to deal with customs, not without risk. A girlfriend I'll call Rosa practiced a technique she called Throw Them a Bone. She would declare a bottle of Chanel along with her other purchases, which took her over her exemption limit. But she also stashed one or two from a lesser-known brand such as Lubin in her husband's shaving kit, and somehow forgot to disclose that. 

If sent to an inspection, Rosa chose a booth staffed by a male officer, as she swore women agents looked at her more closely.  

Some of you might be thinking, Whew! Good thing I don't wear fragrance!

But if you do, don't be daunted. Scent is a sensuous pleasure that dependably lifts my spirits no matter what the season or occasion. I will not be stoppered.


 






Comments

LauraH said…
Very useful information. Nice groaner at the end:-)
Allison said…
I love Perfumeniche! Gwen has such detailed description of each perfume it’s very helpful when trying to avoid certain ingredients or when you are searching for a rose that isn’t all rose-y but has a little spice! Her descriptions have encouraged me to try fragrances I might have avoided. My current love is Gris Charnal by BDK but it’s definitely ‘date night’ stuff so my other love Haunted Rose is my quotidian go to. The nice thing about the decants is you can sample and love or give away but also buy multiples of the same scent for that season. I don’t wear as much scent as I used to for various reasons and when I do I wear just enough that I know it’s there and so does my husband! Nothing so janky as a woman reeking of some ungodly scent, especially in a restaurant or when visiting the ill. There is a popular ingredient in certain drug store perfumes that is the text book of ‘stinky old lady’ even when worn by the young. I think it is neroli but not sure.
I buy a few decants to last the season and if I’m still in love next year maybe buy a bottle or talk someone into buying it for me! Thank you for the purchasing tips.
Duchesse said…
Allison: I always have a couple Perfumeniche decants in my bag and have even given one to semi-strangers like the seatmate on a train (Bella Freud's "Ginsberg is God") or the barista in the coffee shop who said she loved perfume but had allergies (Hiram Green's "Arbole".) And they're ideal for travel. When I met my scent-loving nephew halfway across the continent, Gwen assembled a little pack of men's fragrances for him and women's for his partner—big hit.
If you purchase something from abroad, ask them if they will ship USPS, for instance, from the USA or regular post from other countries. You will not have to pay all those crazy fees.
Duchesse said…
Vancouver Barbara: I know about that and thought of mentioning it, It is worth a try, though in IME vendors have their preferred shippers (often benefitting from discounts) and have told me they do not want to go to a postoffice— they can get parcel pickup or drop ship from a point nearby. INeKE, in this example, declined to use USPS. Vendors who do ship via their own national mail will hand off to Canada Post, and given its strikes and slowdowns over the past two years, I am wary of its performance. I have had some major delivery issues, with zero customer service. But it's an option and thanks for mentioning it.
Duchesse said…
All: Yesterday I received an email criticizing me for buying an American product. The reader said, "As a fellow Canadian I am very sorry to see that you are still supporting the USA by purchasing goods from there. We are in a war, not of our choosing, and the best way we can hurt them is by hurting their economy. Yes, it is going to hurt but what choice do we have."

I replied, and said (edited for brevity): "I agree wholly about your comment, because in this case I did indeed buy a US-made product. And thought hard about it both for my personal purchase, and what’s on the blog.

My main reason for showing US products and even occasionally buying: I know artisans in the US who, b/c of the tariffs, are being killed by the price for their materials, struggling to survive. I’ve known them for 10-25 years and don’t want to see them fail because of a made-up war. I show the occasional US-sold product (from such independent makers)—and make sure to show Canadian equivalents* in the same post. I also encourage readers to shop locally and buy secondhand. "

I appreciated her causing me to think about my limits, and what I'm doing. She would like a total boycott of goods from the US, but that means artisans and tiny business owners like INeKE might lose their livelihoods, along with others in Canada, Europe and Japan. It's a war everyone loses.

* I should have said "Canadian or other non-US-made equivalents", because sometimes there isn't a Canadian equivalent.
KH said…
I’m an American and offer my sincere apologies, which accomplish nothing except to remind anyone reading that many are not willingly aboard this train on whatever unfortunate route this is. It seems likely to me that this includes many creatives and small business owners.

I hope others will show similar discernment as Duchesse in choosing when and how to make their feelings known. Unfortunately, US actions are kind of monolithic, but little is accomplished by a complete boycott. I invite you to join me in avoiding larger corporations that have caved and cowed to protect their interests.
Duchesse said…
KH: Thank you.The tariffs are painful and even disastrous both for small business persons in both Canada and the US. My favourite lingerie company, Understance, based in Vancouver, will close in July.
noreen said…
i am severely limiting my exposure to us made goods wherever possible and have started disengaging from as many online companies as possible too. my favourite perfumes are from jo malone, floris and penhaligons which luckily are all uk brands who do ship to australia for a semi reasonable cost and without strange tariffs
Duchesse said…
noreen: Your favourites have a distributor in your country, so you will evade the burden of importing yourself. It is only when you become captivated by a fragrance with no point of sale in your country that you're cast into that complication. All of your companies make beautiful fragrances and fit into the first point I made about managing cost of the product (not shipping), as across the board the prices have gone up more than inflation. City Perfume, an Australian company, lists all your brands except instead of Jo Malone, carry her new line, Jo Loves. She sold Jo Malone to Estée Lauder.
Tom said…
Everything is too complicated for people like me/us who try to consume responsibly. For instance, as mentioned above, Estee Lauder own Jo Malone. Ronald Lauder is one of the zillionaires who are behind DT's Greenland push. Boycotting counties sounds good, but my daughter is a small business/artist in the USA. Her best friend is an Iranian artist. Another is Israeli. None of these people supports what their home governments are doing.

At the moment, I'm really not buying anything new, except for really small business created goods. That is because I am lucky enough not to need anything.

By the way, previous comments never appeared--perhaps this one will go into the ether as well.
Duchesse said…
Tom/eva: Your comments for some reason always end up in my moderation folder which means I have to approve them first, and I might not get to that the day you comment (or sorry to say longer, if. I'm busy) so it looks like they are in ether. They do get approved and posted, so please keep commenting! Yes, cross-border trade is complicated but IMO worthwhile to consider, both in terms of tariffs and the wider matter of who owns the companies we support via purchases or investments. Your daughter is exactly the kind of artist I want to continue to support. It helps to know the parents ;)
Duchesse said…
All: I just received Ineke Ruuland's e-mail announcing the wind-down of her perfume line, INeKE, over the next few months. She will be opening a perfume raw materials supply business, the Perfumery Studio, as her next step. Bottles of some of her fragrances and sample sets are still available.

The posts with the most