Making giving an art

A Susanfriend removed most of the lightbulbs in her basement, because she could save a few dollars on her electric bill. She kept a flashlight at the top of the stairs but forgot to mention that. Damn near killed myself going down there in the dark!

"Everybody's cheap about something!", she said as she offered a makeshift icebag for my knee. I wondered what my thing was, but I'm a hypocrite, so think of myself as "frugal"—while other people are cheap

What's being cheap?   

Cheapness resides more often in the eye of the receiver than the donor.  Rachel gave me a 4/5 full bottle of perfume that she knew I wore, but on her smelled like "the bottom of my granny's purse"—and I was thrilled. But when a neighbour arrived for a holiday dinner and proffered a a bottle of wine with one-third missing because "I wanted some with my lunch", it felt cheap. 

But I don't really care; let him have his wine. What gets my Irish up is when people refuse to contribute in any way to charities; they say their tax dollars fund social benefits, or that that "those people game the system." ("Those people" is code for immigrants.) Most people I know, though, give their time, donate goods or pledge financial support.

This year, I see more persons than I recall ever before sleeping rough; families who use the food bank next door come every week now, not only near the end of the month. The stats confirm my impression: A leap in the cost of housing (a 170% increase for rental units in Montréal since 2019) has created an affordable-rent crisis, and food banks report a nearly 25% rise in assistance from a year ago.

The easiest way to support a charity is replace gift-giving to friends with a contribution to their cause. The Susanfriend with the dark basement makes a December donation to HelpAge Canada; I in turn give in her name to the Alzheimer Society of Toronto. Some friends are more amenable than others; when I asked Ruth if she would like a personal gift or a donation, she said, "Both!"

Some women enjoy hands-on helping, such as delivering meals for Meals on Wheels, others prefer sponsoring someone for a hike or bike-a-thon— and today I especially want to highlight giving that goes beyond the usual methods. 

Heart Award: Ethel's conversation group

"Giving" does not only mean writing a cheque. I'm moved by my friend Ethel, a retired educator who volunteers to lead a free weekly French conversation group for immigrants to Quebec, hosted by a community centre. These adults meet weekly to practice their French through Ethel's assortment of activities; in addition to gently coaching conversations, she presents Québecois music, poetry, traditions and tips about coping with our frigid winters. 

She said, when I mentioned her skillful animation, that the attendees gave back to her immeasurably. 

Art Award: Crafted for Courage

In 2025, friends and I had an original and exciting opportunity, several as knitters, others as donors.


The project that generated this spirited, uplifting philanthropy was 2025's Crafted for Courage, the which created over 450 quilts hand-made by Montréal women, who donated their time and yarn stashes to produce thousands of squares then linked into striking blankets. Last May, they were displayed at a public art installation and sale that raised over $70, 000 distributed among four local agencies for women affected by domestic violence. 

Here's just one of the quilts:



The founder, Nori Bortoluzzi (Fondation Nota Bene) replicated an idea that originated in Italy, where the project is called Viva Vittoria. This was an enormous endeavour, a full-time commitment for Ms Bortoluzzi and her team. Plans for 2026 will be announced shortly on the Foundation's site.

Though a wealthy donor could have written a cheque for even more than the sale netted. the sheer power of the exhibition of the quilts made an indelible impression and demonstrated the healing power of art.

Art, activism and help for women in transition: a natural for me. Which causes open your heart and inspire you to give?  

 






Comments

Beth said…
Charitable giving is important to us and has mostly replaced traditional gifts within our family. We give to refugee relief, prison ministry, homeless and food precarity causes, and we also give to support the arts because it's where our hearts and lives have been spent and because, more than ever, our spirits all need what the arts give us.
Leslie said…
I donate to food banks throughout the year, but have added extra since our government withheld food benefits during the government shutdown. Donations to charities rather than gifts to family and friends. When I married at 50 and didn’t need my living and dining room furniture In the new home, I donated it all to an organization that provided housing for abused women and families. So much more satisfying than I would have been by selling it.
I am shocked that the cost of rental units has risen 170% in the past 6 years in Montreal. That is unconscionable. I read that 154,000 school children were homeless in New York City last year. We are failing as a nation.
Jean S said…
I have had a community garden plot for 25 years. Though the years, various attempts to donate extra veggies to various food banks would spring up and then fizzle out. But three years ago, three organized and indefatigable women created a harvest program that is proving to be a real success. Just this last season, we seeded 2,500 plants for our fellow gardeners and harvested 4,000 lbs of vegetables for our local food bank.

Right now, our main growing season is done in Oregon, so I'm buying items for the food bank--which, by the way, got its start in 2009 or so when a local middle school student realized that some of his friends didn't have enough to eat.
royleen said…
The local food bank is always my first give. They know how to stretch a dollar! Also, public radio, the local library, political causes, but always the food bank.
KH said…
I just got home from the food bank and diaper pantry that serves the east side of my US city. In 3 hours, 104 families consisting of 456 people and over 6000 pounds of food distributed. This is double the normal # of families and this despite having had extra pantries in the last weeks because of our nonsense. I’ve given regularly but my schedule worked out today and it felt right and good to be there doing the work. Other things we support are public media, our church, a free health clinic, and a nonprofit I’m on the Board of. Here in the US it may have once been reasonable, tho wrong, to assume the government was taking care of things but no one should have that illusion anymore. I’m glad to be able to give and willing to do it, but I looked at people today - so many on the margins of life -and wondered at our collective failures in a society of such plenty that such efforts should even be necessary.
avicennia said…
In the Passage, I may be the odd person on this one. I love giving gifts. I seek gifts that will make someone smile, will introduce them to something new, like a new cuisine or a new experience, or be useful or practical to them. I want people in my orbit to know that I’ve given some thought to them, their needs, and what makes them happy. I work in my Christmas gift list all year round and snap things up as I see them. My granddaughter’s best friend is an immigrant from Ukraine—the grandmother was an engineer and the father was in IT. Here they are truck drivers, cleaners, construction workers and care givers. I search out both practical gifts and special gifts—silk scarf for beauty or something to make long hauls more comfortable. I have strong opinions—my charitable giving is my business. Friends and family deserve gifts to make them feel valued and loved.
Jane in London said…
My carer role and wider family responsibilities don't leave me much time to volunteer. But there are 4 charities that I have supported on a regular monthly basis for many, many years. They all involve people working in conditions that often require them to be very brave: MSF, the British Red Cross, the Royal National Lifeboat Institution and Save the Children. Anyone who has ever witnessed the (unpaid) crew rushing towards a lifeboat station, ready to put to sea at night in a violent storm, will be in no doubt at all of their bravery! I give ad hoc extra payments when there's a disaster that makes extra calls on these organisations, and I feel very fortunate (and grateful) that I am in a position to support them. But I like to keep charitable giving separate from gift giving.
Duchesse said…
Beth: Thanks for the mention of supporting the arts. In return, I have noticed a number of local cultural institutions offering special prices to those for whom performances are a financial stress, and also a ticket category which makes such discounts possible.
Duchesse said…
Leslie: Long known as a city of cheap rents, Montréal attracted many persons who needed that to launch careers as entrepreneurs and artists so depended on low-cost apartments. No longer so, but rent stabilization still makes it one of the more affordable cities of comparable size in Canada.
Duchesse said…
Jean S: What a touching and personal form of philanthropy. As an aside, I have a deep almost inexplicable love for community gardens. We participate in collection of surplus food from our local huge outdoor market.
Duchesse said…
royleen: Food first, because without that, no family can undertake other fundamental tasks of life.
Duchesse said…
Leslie: I miss the days when charity stores accepted all kinds of furniture (save mattresses), Now those stores will not take upholstered pieces so people drag it to the curb, though some churches have organized ways to drop off good used furniture for refugees, who arrive with nothing.
Duchesse said…
KH: That's a sobering stat and thankful those clients could be served. This might be a record year for food banks. One of ours has expanded to offering warm coats and boots, especially for children.
Duchesse said…
avicenna: If you search the sidebar, which lists posts by topics, you will see me regularly posting on gifts: ideas for gifts (such as last week's "homemade treats" post) but also luxury or special items—because I absolutely love delighting someone as you do. Making people feel, as you said " valued and loved" is 100% my kind of thing. It is not an either/or, is it? And, this is a time of year to make those struggling feel valued by providing sustenance when they need it.
Duchesse said…
Jane in London: Thank you for pointing out that many who are themselves volunteers, and in difficult situations, appreciate donations. My friends who have pivoted from personal gift giving only do so at Christmas, they are delighted to get birthday, anniversary or "just because" gifts! When I visited the social service agency next door I heard one woman using the food bank say how she missed the scented soap her husband, now detained in Ukraine, in the army, always gave her at Christmas. She and her children, resettled here, have not seen him for four years. Another staff member and I are doing a little Secret Santa gifting there. It feels wonderful when an opportunity like that pops up.

The posts with the most